1816-1820 – UNKNOWN
1821-1823 – Alfred Benedict
1823-1825 – Gardiner Conklin
1825-1827 – Seth Eddy
1827-1828 – William V.K. McLean
1828-1830 – Seth Eddy
1830-1831 – Jesse Warren
1831-1834 – George Palmer
1834-1836 – Lewis Lawrence
1836-1841 – Medad Cardel
1841-1842 – John Smith
1842-1845 – Daniel Brott( Bratt)
1845-1846 – Gilbert N. Lansing
1846-1847 – William M. Bartlett
1847-1848 – Charles Wing
1848-1866 – No Records
1866-1867 – J.W. Haight
1867-1868 – John Wetsel
1868-1870 – Philip Mosher
1870-1872 – Aaron Gallyer
1872-1873 – John B. Newland
1873-1874 – G.V. Lansing
1874-1876 – P.V. Wetsel
1876-1877 – P. VanVechten
1877-1878 – William L. Denison
1878-1879 – J.W. Haight
1879-1881 – Rial Newland
1881-1882 – John Wetsel
1882-1887 – Edward Wood
1888-1889 – Rial Newland
1889-1890 – Howland K. Heusted
1890-1891 – Edward Wood
1891-1892 – William R. Palmer
1892-1893 – Peter VanVechten
1893-1894 – William Denison
1894-1897 – Henry Newland
1897-1898 – John Fuller
1898-1901 – Chauncey Deyoe
1901-1902 – John Britten
1902-1904 – George Hudson
1904-1905 – John Fuller
1905-1906 – George Hudson
1906-1907 – Frank Neilson
1907-1908 – Elmer Pemble
1908-1908 – Edward I. Wood * Died while in office
1909-1910 – William Schermerhorn
1910-1911 – John R. Britten
1911-1912 – Silas P. Haight
1912-1915 – W.R. Palmer
1915-1916 – Ernest C. Tefft
1916-1920 – Fred B. Durham
1920-1926 – John Bradley
1926-1936* – Edward Flynn
1936-1938 – Willard Barker
1938-1944 – John Hoskins
1944-1946 – Harvey H. Powell
1946-1957- August Baurman
1957-1962 – William B. Deuel
1962-1979 – Raymond J. Connor
1979-1991 – David L. Rathbun
1991-1991 – Michael Hanehan
1991-1992 – John Herrick
1992-2015 – Ernest W. Martin Sr.
2015- 2017 – Rick Nelson
2017-2018 – Frank Tatum
2018-Present – Judith Wood-Shaw